Back to: Case Studies

A parcel handed over and signed for at a front door

What Out-of-Area Orders Really Cost a Shopify Store

Out-of-area orders cost a Shopify store more than the refunded sale. An order from outside your delivery route means a cancellation, an apology and a refund, and Shopify keeps the card fee. A free-shipping parcel to a remote postal code brings a carrier surcharge that you pay yourself. Each one is small. Over a year, they can add up to more than a thousand dollars, and a few customers.

The figures below come from published carrier and Shopify fees, checked in November 2026.

A familiar evening

It’s Thursday evening, and you’re planning tomorrow’s deliveries. You drive the van yourself, so you know every street on the route. One new order isn’t on any of them: the address is an hour past the edge of your area.

So you stop. You write to the customer, explain, cancel and refund. They paid in thirty seconds and hoped to have their order by the weekend. Now they’re looking elsewhere, and your evening is an hour shorter.

The same week, the carrier invoice arrives for the parcels you ship farther away. One line is a remote-area surcharge on an order you shipped for free. Nothing went badly wrong. It just came out of your margin.

Why do out-of-area orders happen?

Out-of-area orders happen because a shipping rate reaches farther than your van. Shopify’s local delivery only shows to customers inside the area you set, by distance up to 160 km or by a list of postal codes (Shopify’s guide to local delivery). A shipping rate for your whole province reaches every address in it, including the ones off your route.

Remote postal codes sit inside the same regions, so a free-shipping rate for a whole province covers its remote postal codes too, as our guide to Shopify shipping rules and zones → explains. A line such as “we only deliver to …” on your product pages helps, but the order still goes through when checkout offers a rate.

What does an out-of-area order cost?

An out-of-area order costs you a refund or a surcharge. If you deliver locally, you cancel and refund it, and Shopify keeps the original card fee (Shopify Payments refunds). If you ship for free, the carrier bills you: in 2026, FedEx charges at least CAD 27.95 per shipment to an address outside its delivery area in Canada, according to its 2026 rate changes.

What happens

What it costs

You cancel and refund an order

The card fee, which Shopify keeps

Someone writes to the customer

About 15 minutes

FedEx delivers to a remote postal code

From CAD 27.95 in Canada

It costs more the farther out the address is. FedEx charges at least CAD 124.40 for the territories and some postal codes in five provinces. In the US, UPS charges USD 16.50 per package to a remote area, and USD 46.25 in Alaska (UPS domestic charges). The card fee you lose on a refund is 2.8% plus 30 cents on the Basic plan in Canada (Shopify’s pricing).

Five remote parcels a month on free shipping comes to CAD 1,677 a year with FedEx in Canada.

That’s for a store shipping a thousand orders a month, with one parcel in 200 going somewhere remote. To find your own number, look for remote-area lines on your carrier invoices and count last quarter’s “can’t deliver” cancellations.

The part that doesn’t show on an invoice

The bigger cost is harder to price. A customer who paid, then heard you can’t deliver, has little reason to try again. And every case pulls you away from the deliveries that were going out on time.

When we set up delivery rules for Shopify stores at msmtech, we start with the last three months of “can’t deliver” cancellations and remote surcharges. They show which postal codes belong on the list.

What store owners told us

Merchants who use Ultimate Postal Code Blocker have written about it in their App Store reviews. This is their own account, not a figure we have checked:

“…the major cities in Canada so I didn't receive unexpected remote delivery charges.”

— Vermilion Jewellery, App Store review, September 2025

Vermilion Jewellery wanted to ship to Canada’s major cities only. It wrote that the app was very easy to install, and that we quickly added an allow-list option for it.

How do you stop out-of-area orders before payment?

You stop out-of-area orders at checkout, while the customer is still there. They see a short message before they pay, and Thursday evening stays yours.

If you only deliver locally and no shipping rate covers the same addresses, Shopify’s local delivery already does this, as our guide to Shopify same-day delivery → shows. When the problem postal codes sit inside a region you ship to, Ultimate Postal Code Blocker, the app we build at msmtech, checks the postal or ZIP code at checkout and hides delivery for the codes you block, or for any code not on your list, with a message in your own words. Local pickup stays open, and you can keep a rate priced for remote areas. It costs USD 8.99 a month, with a 30-day free trial, as of November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Do I get the card fee back when I refund a Shopify order?

No. Shopify says the original card fee isn’t returned when you refund a Shopify Payments order. On a CAD 80 order on the Basic plan in Canada, that’s CAD 2.54 you don’t get back.

Should I block remote postal codes or charge more?

Charge more when a rate covers the cost, such as a postal service or a higher flat rate, and allow only that rate for those codes. Block them when no rate covers the cost or you can’t deliver at all.

Can customers get around a postal code block with express checkout?

Not with Ultimate Postal Code Blocker. The check runs inside Shopify’s checkout, and the app stops express checkouts from completing without a postal code.

No off-the-shelf solution? We'll build it.