Back to: Case Studies

A woman working on a laptop at a table by the window

What a Fraudulent Order Really Costs a Shopify Store

A fraudulent order costs a Shopify store almost everything it spent on it. A stolen card pays, the parcel ships, and weeks later the real cardholder asks their bank for the money back. You lose the goods, the label and the fees, and someone spends an hour on a dispute that is hard to win. On a CAD 150 order, that comes to about CAD 120.

The figures below come from Shopify’s published fees, checked in November 2026, applied to a typical CAD 150 order.

An email that comes weeks later

It’s Tuesday morning, and an email from Shopify says a customer has disputed a payment. You look up the order. It went out weeks ago, packed and labelled like the rest.

Nothing about it looked wrong. The name, the address and the card all went through. But the person who owns the card never placed it, and has asked their bank for the money back. The amount has already left your balance.

So you stop and gather what you have: the order, the tracking, the proof of delivery. You suspect it won’t be enough. The parcel went to someone else’s door, and that doesn’t show the cardholder ordered it.

Why do fraudulent orders get through?

A fraudulent order is paid with a card the buyer doesn’t own. It looks like any other order, so it gets packed and shipped. The problem only shows up weeks later, when the real cardholder disputes the charge with their bank.

Shopify does look. Every store gets fraud analysis on the order page, with signs such as a location that doesn’t match the card. A low, medium or high recommendation comes with the Grow plan or higher, or with Shopify Payments (Shopify’s guide to fraud analysis). But a flagged order isn’t held or cancelled for you. Unless someone checks it first, it ships with the rest.

What does a fraudulent order cost?

A fraudulent order that ships and comes back as a chargeback costs about CAD 120 on a CAD 150 sale. The CAD 150 goes back to the cardholder; what you lose is what you spent on the order. With Shopify Payments, the disputed amount and a CAD 15 chargeback fee leave your balance as soon as the dispute opens (Shopify’s chargeback guide).

What happens

What it costs

The goods and the label go to someone else

About CAD 78, if goods cost 40% of the price

The bank takes the payment back

A CAD 15 chargeback fee

Someone gathers evidence and responds

About an hour

The card fee on the sale doesn’t come back either: 2.8% + 30¢ on Shopify’s Basic plan in Canada (Shopify’s pricing). You usually have 7 to 21 days to respond, and if you win, the amount and the fee are returned. But delivery to a stranger’s door is weak evidence when the cardholder says they never ordered.

Two fraudulent orders a month comes to about CAD 2,870 a year.

That’s for a store shipping a thousand orders a month, where 1 in 500 slips through. Your own number starts in your Shopify admin: count last quarter’s fraud chargebacks and divide by three.

The part that doesn’t show on an invoice

The bigger cost is your chargeback rate. Shopify counts every dispute a customer opens, including the ones you win. A high rate can lead to a reserve on your payouts, or to a program where eligible disputes are refunded to the customer automatically (Shopify’s guide to monitoring chargebacks).

Two other costs are real but hard to price. Stock went to a fraudster instead of a paying customer. And checks that are too strict turn good customers away. The aim is to stop the few without slowing down the many.

How do you stop a fraudulent order before it ships?

You stop it before the parcel leaves, or better, before the payment goes through. Wait for Shopify’s fraud analysis to finish before you fulfil an order. Hold the medium- and high-risk ones and contact the customer first. And block buyers you’ve already had fraud from, as our guide to blocking customers on Shopify → explains.

UCB: Country & Fraud Blocker, the app we build at msmtech, gives each visitor a risk score and can keep risky visitors out of your store. It can stop checkout for shipping countries, email addresses or phone numbers you’ve blocked. For a risky order that still comes through, it can tag the order, email you, or cancel it after a delay you choose; a cancellation is final, and refunds stay your decision. It has a free plan, and every plan has every feature; plans differ only in the visits they include.

At msmtech we suggest starting in Watch only, which records scores without blocking anyone, and choosing a threshold once you’ve seen your own visitors’ scores. Address mistakes are a different problem, covered in our look at Shopify checkout address validation →.

Frequently asked questions

Should I cancel a high-risk order on Shopify?

Shopify suggests verifying, cancelling or refunding a high-risk order before you ship it, and notes that a single sign doesn’t show an order’s overall risk. When the evidence is thin, contact the customer first. A real order cancelled by mistake is a lost sale.

Does Shopify pay for fraudulent chargebacks?

Only through Shopify Protect, for US merchants with a US Shopify Payments account. It reimburses the amount and fee of a fraudulent chargeback on eligible Shop Pay orders fulfilled with tracking within 7 days (Shopify’s guide to Shopify Protect). Canadian stores can’t use it, so the loss is theirs.

What chargeback rate is too high on Shopify?

Shopify doesn’t publish a number. It says a high rate can lead to a payout reserve or a dispute program, so watch the 90-day chargeback rate report in Analytics and act on any rise.

No off-the-shelf solution? We'll build it.